Theater - Awards & Accolades

2024
Nominee
Tony Awards

Best Leading Actor in a Play, Patriots

2024
Nominee
Drama Desk Awards

Best Leading Actor in a Play, Patriots

2024
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, Patriots

2024
Nominee
Outer Critics Circle Awards

Outstanding Lead Performer in a Broadway Play, Patriots

2019
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, Socrates

2008
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, Hamlet

2007
Recipient
Obie Awards

Distinguished Performance by an Actor, The Voysey Inheritance

2007
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, The Voysey Inheritance

2007
Recipient
Joe A. Callaway Award

Edward Voysey in The Voysey Inheritance

2007
Nominee
Lucille Lortel Award

Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play, The Voysey Inheritance

2006
Nominee
Lortel Award

Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play, Measure for Pleasure

2006
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, Measure For Pleasure

2005
Winner
Drama Desk Awards

Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play, The Pillowman

2005
Nominee
Tony Awards

Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play, The Pillowman

2005
Recipient
The New Dramatists Charles Bowden Actor Award
2005
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, The Pillowman

1997
Winner
Elliot Norton Boston Theatre Award

Outstanding Actor, Large Company for performance in Long Day's Journey into Night

1995
Nominee
Drama League Awards

Distinguished Performance Award, Old Wicked Songs

1992
Recipient
Lincoln Center Martin E. Segal Award

Film & TV - Awards & Accolades

2022
Nominee
Primetime Emmy Award
Primetime Emmy Awards

Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie Dopesick  (2021) as "Richard Sackler".

2020
Nominee
HCA Award
Hollywood Critics Association Midseason Awards

Best Supporting Actor Shirley  (2020)

2018
Winner
ICS Award
International Cinephile Society Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
ALFS Award
London Critics Circle Film Awards

ALFS AwardSupporting Actor of the Year Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Winner
Chairman's Vanguard Award
Palm Springs International Film Festival

The Shape of Water  (2017)

2018
Nominee
Gold Derby Film Award
Gold Derby Awards

Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
Ensemble Cast The Shape of Water  (2017)

2018
Nominee
AFCA Award
Austin Film Critics Association

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
Critics Choice Award
Broadcast Film Critics Association Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
Primetime Emmy
Primetime Emmy Awards

Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie The Looming Tower  (2018) as "Richard Clarke".

2018
Winner
OFCC Award
Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Awards

Best Body of Work
Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
The Shape of Water  (2017)
The Post  (2017)

2018
Nominee
OFTA Film Award
Online Film & Television Association

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
Best Ensemble The Shape of Water  (2017)

2018
Winner
Dorian Award
GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics

Film Performance of the Year - Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
GAFCA Award
Georgia Film Critics Association (GAFCA)

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
EDA Award
Alliance of Women Film Journalists

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
HFCS Award
Houston Film Critics Society Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2018
Nominee
INOCA
International Online Cinema Awards (INOCA)

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017) Runner-up

2018
Nominee
NSFC Award
National Society of Film Critics Awards, USA

Best Supporting Actor
Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
The Shape of Water  (2017)
The Post  (2017)

2017
Winner
LAOFCS Award
Los Angeles Online Film Critics Society Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
Tied with Patrick Stewart for Logan (2017).

2017
Nominee
OFTA Television Award
Online Film & Television Association

Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture or Limited Series Fargo  (2014)

2017
Nominee
TFCA Award
Toronto Film Critics Association Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
CFCA Award
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Winner
SDFCS Award
San Diego Film Critics Society Awards

Best Body of Work
The Post  (2017)
Call Me by Your Name  (2017)
The Shape of Water  (2017)

2017
Nominee
SFFCC Award
San Francisco Film Critics Circle

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
Gold Derby TV Award
Gold Derby Awards

TV Movie/Mini Supporting Actor Fargo  (2014)

2017
Nominee
ICP Award
Indiewire Critics' Poll

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017) 4th place

2017
Nominee
FFCC Award
Florida Film Critics Circle Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
PCC Award
Phoenix Critics Circle

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
WAFCA Award
Washington DC Area Film Critics Association Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
OFCS Award
Online Film Critics Society Awards

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2017
Nominee
VVFP Award
Village Voice Film Poll

Best Supporting Performance Call Me by Your Name  (2017) 5th place

2017
Nominee
ACCA
Awards Circuit Community Awards

Best Actor in a Supporting Role Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

Best Cast Ensemble Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

Best Cast Ensemble The Shape of Water  (2017)

2017
Nominee
INOCA
International Online Cinema Awards (INOCA)

Best Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or TV Movie Fargo  (2014)

2017
Nominee
PCC Award
Phoenix Critics Circle

Best Supporting Actor Call Me by Your Name  (2017)

2016
Nominee
Gold Derby Film Award
Gold Derby Awards

Ensemble Cast Steve Jobs  (2015)

2016
Nominee
Actor
Screen Actors Guild Awards

Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture Trumbo  (2015)

2015
Nominee
ACCA
Awards Circuit Community Awards

Best Cast Ensemble Steve Jobs  (2015)

2014
Nominee
Gold Derby Film Award
Gold Derby Awards

Ensemble Cast Blue Jasmine  (2013)

2014
Nominee
Actor
Screen Actors Guild Awards

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series Boardwalk Empire  (2010)

2013
Nominee
COFCA Award
Central Ohio Film Critics Association

Best Ensemble Lincoln  (2012)

2013
Nominee
Actor
Screen Actors Guild Awards

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series Boardwalk Empire  (2010)

2013
Nominee
Gold Derby Film Award
Gold Derby Awards

Ensemble Cast Lincoln  (2012)

2012
Winner
Actor
Screen Actors Guild Awards

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series Boardwalk Empire  (2010)

2012
Nominee
SDFCS Award
San Diego Film Critics Society Awards

Best Ensemble Performance Seven Psychopaths  (2012)

2012
Winner
BSFC Award
Boston Society of Film Critics Awards

Best Ensemble Cast Seven Psychopaths  (2012)

2011
Winner
Actor
Screen Actors Guild Awards

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series Boardwalk Empire  (2010)

2010
Winner
Robert Altman Award
Film Independent Spirit Awards

A Serious Man  (2009)

2010
Nominee
ALFS Award
London Critics Circle Film Awards

Actor of the Year A Serious Man  (2009)

2010
Winner
Virtuoso Award
Santa Barbara International Film Festival

A Serious Man  (2009)

2010
Nominee
Golden Globe
Golden Globes, USA

Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Comedy or Musical A Serious Man  (2009)

2010
Nominee
INOCA
International Online Cinema Awards (INOCA)

Best Actor A Serious Man  (2009)

2010
Nominee
ICS Award
International Cinephile Society Awards

Best Actor A Serious Man  (2009) 2nd place

2009
Nominee
CFCA Award
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards

Best Actor A Serious Man  (2009)

2009
Nominee
BSFC Award
Boston Society of Film Critics Awards

Best Ensemble Cast A Serious Man  (2009)

2009
Winner
Satellite Award
Satellite Awards

Best Actor in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical A Serious Man  (2009)

2009
Nominee
VVFP Award
Village Voice Film Poll

Best Actor A Serious Man  (2009) 7th place

2009
Nominee
Gotham Independent Film Award
Gotham Awards

Best Ensemble Performance A Serious Man  (2009)

2009
Nominee
ICP Award
Indiewire Critics' Poll

Best Lead Performance A Serious Man  (2009) 7th place